The role of a leader in any organisation is not just significant; it’s crucial. When leaders fail to fulfil their responsibilities, the consequences can be severe for all stakeholders involved. In today’s interconnected world, leadership is not just about holding a title; it’s about steering an organisation and its people toward success. However, when leaders fail to lead correctly, the impact can be disastrous, affecting employees, investors, and the broader community. The fallout from ineffective leadership can be significant, underscoring the need for effective leadership.
A leader who doesn’t lead properly fails to provide clear direction, needs more accountability, and inspires andmotivates their team. Such leaders often avoid making difficult decisions, shy away from responsibility when things go wrong, and neglect their role as a guiding force. This failure of leadership can have far-reaching effects, impacting not just the organisation but also its employees, investors, and the broader community.
History and recent events provide several examples of leaders who need to lead more effectively, causing significant harm to their organisations and stakeholders. One notable case is Elizabeth Holmes, the former CEO of Theranos. Holmes promised groundbreaking advancements in medical testing, but her leadership was marked by deception and a need for moretransparency. As the company’s promises unravelled, stakeholders—including investors, employees, and patients—were left to deal with the fallout. The resulting legal consequences and loss of trust had a ripple effect, damaging not just the company but also the reputation of the healthcare sector.
Another example is Adam Neumann, the co-founder of WeWork. Neumann’s leadership was characterised by erratic decision-making, over-expansion, and a focus on personal gain over organisational stability. Employees and investors suffered the consequences when the company’s valuation plummeted, facing layoffs and financial losses. Neumann’s failure to lead effectively resulted in a significant loss of confidence among stakeholders and highlighted the dangers of poor leadership in a rapidly growing company.
On the political stage, Viktor Yanukovych, the former President of Ukraine, exemplifies the dangers of ineffective leadership. Yanukovych’s tenure was marked by corruption, a lack of accountability, and an unwillingness to listen to the people’s will. His failure to lead led to widespread protests, a political crisis, and removal from power. The country and its citizens faced significant challenges due to his leadership failures, underscoring the importance of effective governance.
When leaders fail to lead correctly, the effects on stakeholders can be devastating. Trust is often the first casualty, as stakeholders lose confidence in the organisation and its leadership. This relationship breakdown can lead to financial instability, affecting investors, employees, and others dependent on the organisation’s success. Employee morale also suffers, leading to disengagement, reduced productivity, and higher turnover rates. Additionally, the organisation’s reputation can take a hit, making attracting and retaining talent, customers, and investors difficult.
Despite the challenges posed by ineffective leadership, stakeholders still need recourse. One of the most important steps is to demand accountability. Stakeholders must hold leaders responsible for their actions by insisting on transparency in decision-making and creating channels for feedback. In cases where leadership is irredeemably ineffective, stakeholders can push for leadership changes through board interventions, shareholder actions, or other means.
Another key strategy is diversification. By diversifying investments and partnerships, stakeholders can reduce their dependency on a single entity and protect themselves from the fallout of poor leadership. Strengthening stakeholder communication is also crucial, as it helps identify issues early and create a united front in addressing leadership failures.
Finally, focusing on resilience is essential. Organisations can build resilience through solid governance, ethical practices, and a clear strategy, which can help mitigate the effects of poor leadership.
Leadership is more than just a title—it’s a commitment to guiding an organisation and its stakeholders toward success. When leaders fail to lead correctly, the consequences can be severe, but stakeholders can navigate the challenges proactively and continue to thrive despite the difficulties. Accountability, communication, and a shared commitment to resilience and ethical practices are key to surviving and overcoming the dangers of ineffective leadership.
***
Thabang Chiloane is the Chairperson of the Institute for Stakeholder Relations in Southern Africa (ISRSA). He writes in his personal capacity.